US LTL: Fuel Supports Earnings While Volume Recovery Remains Uneven
Tags: LTL earnings fuel-surcharges operating-leverage
Value Score: 8/10
Core Conclusion: J.P. Morgan remains constructive on the longer-term earnings leverage of less-than-truckload carriers but cautious near term. Third-quarter results relied more on higher fuel prices than a broad freight recovery. October volumes and fourth-quarter guidance distinguish improving networks from companies still facing weak density and cost inflation; a fall in diesel prices could reverse part of the earnings support in 2027.
Key Data Moves
Old Dominion's October setback limits near-term leverage. Tonnage was tracking down about 5%-5.5% month on month, versus the ten-year seasonal decline of 3.5%, after a better September. Fourth-quarter revenue guidance of $1.54bn-$1.58bn benefits from an earlier general rate increase, but an operating ratio near 73.5% implies only the low end of normal sequential deterioration after adjusting for the actuarial item. Fringe-benefit inflation remains a headwind (p1).
XPO's pricing trend improves after a third-quarter miss. Yield ex-fuel rose 3.6% year on year in the quarter, below prior guidance, then accelerated to about 5% in October. October tonnage per day was tracking growth in the mid-6% range year on year and above seasonal expectations. Fourth-quarter LTL operating ratio guidance below 82% and full-year improvement of at least 250 basis points, versus at least 200 previously, support the company's own operational improvement story (pp1-2).
Saia is beginning to absorb its expanded footprint. October tonnage per day was tracking up about 10% year on year, broadly consistent with seasonality. Fourth-quarter operating ratio deterioration of about 200 basis points would be better than the normal 250-300, and imply more than 200 basis points of year-on-year improvement. Revenue per shipment excluding fuel accelerated to 5.8% growth. The first $250m repurchase authorization reinforces management's confidence as newer terminals mature (p2).
FedEx Freight's headline revenue yield still depends heavily on fuel. Revenue per shipment rose 8.8% year on year, while yield excluding fuel increased only 0.3%. Fourth-quarter adjusted operating income guidance of $185m-$205m was 17% above consensus at the midpoint. Management's bridge includes a 425-basis-point operating-ratio benefit p